Feature or enhancement
Discussion link: https://discuss.python.org/t/consider-deprecating-and-eventually-removing-b-cli-flag/96903
Currently -b and -bb CLI options do not provide much benefit, but has several corner-cases where they require some work-arounds.
My plan to deprecate them:
- Use regular
stderr output about a deprecation, do not raise a real DeprecationWarning object. Why? Because initconfig.c does not have GIL yet to call C-API and real warnings can mess things up, since -b is also warnings-related. I guess docs + stderr output will be good enough. Downsides: warning filtering and -We and -Wi won't affect this warning.
- 2 versions should be enough for the deprecation, since the only thing required is to simply remove
-b from the command line args
Future plans:
- After the deprecation will end in 3.17, I plan to remove
-b and -bb options (there's an alternative to make them no-op, but it can be suprising for end users that they do nothing)
- I also plan to remove code paths that require
sys.flags.bytes_warning to be set, no warnings will be produced as of 3.17
All other machinery will be kept as-is.
Linked PRs
Feature or enhancement
Discussion link: https://discuss.python.org/t/consider-deprecating-and-eventually-removing-b-cli-flag/96903
Currently
-band-bbCLI options do not provide much benefit, but has several corner-cases where they require some work-arounds.My plan to deprecate them:
stderroutput about a deprecation, do not raise a realDeprecationWarningobject. Why? Becauseinitconfig.cdoes not have GIL yet to call C-API and real warnings can mess things up, since-bis also warnings-related. I guess docs + stderr output will be good enough. Downsides: warning filtering and-Weand-Wiwon't affect this warning.-bfrom the command line argsFuture plans:
-band-bboptions (there's an alternative to make them no-op, but it can be suprising for end users that they do nothing)sys.flags.bytes_warningto be set, no warnings will be produced as of 3.17All other machinery will be kept as-is.
Linked PRs
-band-bbCLI flags in 3.15 #136363